• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls: Authentic NY-Style Pizza with Friendly Service

Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls, located at 307 Prospect St, offers a genuine taste of New York-style pizza in the heart of Niagara Falls. Known for its soft, foldable dough and perfectly curled pepperoni, this spot delivers authentic, flavorful slices that satisfy both locals and visitors craving classic comfort food. Despite occasional phone line issues, the friendly staff ensure quick, efficient service, even during busy times. With a variety of slice options and refreshing beverages, Mario's invites you to enjoy hot, well-crafted pies in a casual, walk-up setting—an ideal find for pizza lovers seeking genuine, no-frills quality near the Falls.

Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls at a glance

  • Address 307 Prospect St, Niagara Falls, NY 14303, United States
  • Phone +1 716-282-2080
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls: Reviews & Ratings

Chase Saxton
5

Friendly staff and good pizza. They were quick to get us our food even though it was busy.

Cherilyn Jones
4

Ok pizza. We popped in for a slice and it wasn’t terrible but wasn’t great either.

Alexis K
5

We walked past Mario’s Pizza twice and almost overlooked it, since it just looked like any other pizza shop. After waiting forever at another restaurant, we decided to leave and give Mario’s a try—and I’m so glad we did! The pizza was amazing: the pepperoni curled perfectly, the dough was soft and foldable without being floppy, and the flavor was spot on. So happy we ended up here—it was definitely worth it!

Lisa Powers
4

The phone number listed on google and also on their front door does not work. We tried to call and order for pick up but got a message saying the number was out of order. So be forewarned if you are staying in a nearby hotel. Thankfully we were staying nearby and didn’t mind the short walk. We wanted to call ahead to order so it was ready to pick up when we got there but again the number was out of service. There was a nice selection slices you can grab to go as well as coolers with sodas and ice tea and bottled water for purchase as well. The pizza was delicious. We had Hawaiian slices and a veggie slice and a cup n char pepperoni slice. Walk up service was fast and easy. We ate at the outdoor tables.

Nathan Didlake
5

Carl Shussie (from Maid of the Midst touring fame) recommended this place. He was not wrong. We lived in Jersey for years and have missed the authentic slice. Love ny style pizza. So glad places like this are serving up hot pies daily!

Ashley Low
5

If you’re dropping by Niagara Falls, you must visit this place!! The pizza was so delicious, I didn’t even get a picture of it because I devoured it in a second. I had a lot of pizzas, but this was just the best. The girls in the counter were so nice as well. The best restaurant I’ve visited here. It made my day! Thank you.

Location

  • Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls
    Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls
    307 Prospect St, Niagara Falls, NY 14303, United States Hotline: +1 716-282-2080

Mario's Pizza - Niagara Falls stands as a humble yet authentic beacon of classic New York-style pizza in the heart of Niagara Falls, NY. Nestled at 307 Prospect Street, this locally cherished pizzeria offers a genuine slice experience that has earned it praise from both residents and visitors alike. Despite an unassuming storefront that might cause some to overlook it, Mario's delivers a surprisingly memorable pizza that resonates with lovers of traditional, foldable, and flavorful slices.

The hallmark of Mario's lies in its perfect balance of a soft, adaptable dough that maintains structure without floppiness and toppings that are thoughtfully prepared. Pepperoni slices curl up just right, creating little pockets of crisp, savory goodness—a detail that authentic pizza connoisseurs will appreciate. The menu features a satisfying variety of slices such as classic pepperoni, Hawaiian, and veggie options, all served fresh with quick, friendly service that remains reliable even during busy times.

Mario's also caters well to on-the-go diners with grab-and-go slices and chilled beverages, making it a convenient spot for a quick meal. Outdoor seating adds to the casual, inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy your pizza at leisure. While some have noted difficulties in reaching the pizzeria by phone, the experience of walking in and sampling the food more than compensates, with many returning customers highlighting the consistent quality and genuine taste reminiscent of true New York-style pies.

For anyone craving authentic, no-frills pizza in Niagara Falls, Mario's Pizza offers a warm welcome and satisfying slices that pay homage to the city's rich pizza tradition. It’s a spot worth discovering—delivering both comfort and flavor with each bite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards